Explore
News
Music
Education
Podcast
Gaming
Sports
Home
Shorts
Ukraine: Peace or surrender? - with John Mearsheimer & Matthew Syed
UnHerd
4,227 views
266 likes
📰 Subscribe to UnHerd today at: https://bit.ly/3Qdkd5y
UnHerd's Freddie Sayers sits down with John Mearsheimer and Matthew Syed to discuss the prospect of a Ukraine peace deal.
Watch it on the UnHerd website: https://unherd.com/watch-listen/ukraine-realist-vs-idealist/
Listen to the podcast: https://plnk.to/unherd?to=page
UnHerd’s Freddie Sayers brings together two starkly opposed voices on the Ukraine war and the future of world order: John Mearsheimer, University of Chicago professor and leading realist, and Matthew Syed, Sunday Times columnist, broadcaster and author.
Mearsheimer has long argued that NATO expansion and Western policy blunders set the stage for Putin’s invasion of Ukraine. From a realist standpoint, he warns that Russia’s position is essentially non-negotiable and that Ukraine must cut a deal now if it is to avoid further devastation. For Mearsheimer, ignoring the hard facts of great-power politics and clinging to Western rhetoric risks only catastrophic escalation.
Syed sees things very differently. In a recent Sunday Times column, he criticised the West’s handling of Ukraine, from the failed Alaska summit. He accused Western governments of failing Ukraine and directly attacked Mearsheimer’s realist position as “morally deranged” and fatally weak. For Syed, only moral clarity and Western resolve — not accommodation with Putin — can change the course of the war.
In this debate, Freddie Sayers asks: Is realism just disguised defeatism? Is idealism dangerously naïve in the age of Trump, Putin and Xi? And, after the White House summit with Zelensky, does the West finally have a coherent strategy — or is Ukraine still being left to fight alone?
Follow UnHerd on social media:
Twitter: https://twitter.com/unherd
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/unherd/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/unherd/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@unherdtv
//TIMECODES//
00:00 - 03:22 - Introduction
03:22 - 37:16 - John Mearsheimer: Why Ukraine cannot win
37:16 - 1:15:31 - Matthew Syed: Why the realists are wrong
1:15:31 - 1:16:09 - Closing thoughts
#UnHerd #UkraineWar #JohnMearsheimer
Show more
177 Commments